Randomized controlled clinical trial to study the efficacy of Priyangvaadi Gana Siddha tail in the management of Parikartika w.s.r. to fissure-in-ano-An Ayurvedic management protocol
Abstract
Sushruta explained about Guda-Roga, i.e. Ano Rectal Disease in Shalya Tantra. It includes no. of disease out of them one is Parikartika," i.e. Fissure – in – Ano. Lifestyle diseases are mainly caused by improper work pattern, stressful life, improper diet intake and improper sleep habits. These causative factors produce indigestion which leads to various lifestyle disorders, specially anorectal disorders like piles, fissure in ano, fistula in ano etc., constitute a significant group. Priyangvaadi Gana siddha tail in the management of Parikartika. The present study is designed as a Randomized, single-blind parallel in which 60 patients will be enrolled. Priyangvaadi Gana Siddha Taila Pichu and Yastimadhu tail Pichu will be given for basti twice a day. Assessment will be done 0th, 7th day, 14thday, and 28th day. The changes are expected to be observed in subjective parameters such as pain bleeding per rectum with itching as well as with objective parameters such as Parikartika Healing. The study is expecting the nonsurgical management of fissure in ano with respect to the impact of Priyangvaadi Gana Siddha tail pichu and Yastimadhu tail Pichu. The research is expecting to be a baseline and benchmark of the prospective studies in Acute Fissure in ano (Parikartika).
Keywords
Parikartika, Yastimadhu tail pichu, Priyangvaadi Gana siddha Taila
Introduction
Sushruta explained about Guda-Roga, i.e. Ano Rectal Disease in Shalya Tantra. It includes no. of disease out of them one is Parikartika," i.e. Fissure – in – Ano. (Dilip, Shilpa, Vinay, Amit, & Khobragade, 2020) Lifestyle diseases are mainly caused by improper work pattern, stressful life, improper diet intake and improper sleep habits. (Steyn & Damasceno, 2006) These causative factors produce indigestion which leads to various lifestyle disorders, specially anorectal disorders like piles, fissure in ano, fistula in ano etc., constitute a significant group. (Foxx-Orenstein, Umar, & Crowell, 2014) Among all anorectal disorders, fissure in ano is the most common disease. Fissure is a longitudinal ulcer in the lower end of the anal canal called fissure – in – Ano.
It is mostly due to constipation. (Shashidharan & Beaty, 2016) Anal Fissure is one of the major causes of pain in the anal region. Pruritus ani is associated with this disease. (Ansari, 2016) The fissure-in-ano can be of two types on the basis of clinical symptoms and durations of the disease is Acute and Chronic fissure in ano.
The two primary signs of this disorder are bleeding and pain; pain is often unbearable. In chronic conditions, sentinel tag and haemorrhoids can be associated with this. In males, anal fissure typically occurs in the midline posterior- 90 percent and 10 percent, much less frequently. Subsequently, a female fissure in ano is common on the anterior midline (60:40). (Jahnny & Ashurst, 2020)
In modern medical science, parikartika can be compared with Fissure in ano (Sarkar, 2016). Vamana–Virecana Vypada, Basti Karma vypada and Upadrava of Atisara, Grahani, Arśa, Udāvarta are the causative factor of parikartika.In this regard. Pathogenesis of parikartika has been explained by acharya Sushruta (Srinivasa & Mamatha, 2020).
The word Parikartika means Parikartanavatvedanaaround guda i.e. cutting type of pain. Parikartika also has symptoms such as pain in the penis, anus, neck of the urinary bladder and umbilical region with flatus cessation (Pandey & Saxena, 2018). References about Parikartika are available from all Bruhatrayi and also mentioned in Kashyap Samhita and later authors of Ayurveda.
Methodology
Trial design
Randomized, single-blind parallel.
Study setting
OPD of Department of Shalyatantra of Ayurveda College and Hospital. (Figure 1 and Figure 2).
Inclusion Criteria
-
The patient having classical signs and symptoms of parikartika will be selected for the present clinical study.
-
Patients of age between 18 to 60 years.
-
Patient suffering from a fissure in ano without any complication.
-
Cooperative patient.
Exclusion Criterion
-
Patients having Parikartika (Fissure-in-ano) secondary to Ulcerative colitis, Syphilis, Crohn's disease, Tuberculosis and Carcinoma of the rectum and anal canal.
-
Patients with infectious diseases like HIV/ Hbs Ag / HCV.
-
Patient with uncontrolled Diabetes and Hypertension.
-
Not willing to give consent.
-
Patients with Perianal abscess, rectal prolapsed and severe local sepsis.
Criteria for discontinuing or modifying allocated interventions
If any complication arises during treatment case will be liable for rejection. The patient will be offered treatment free of cost till the disease subsided.
Follow up period after treatment
28th day after treatment.
Primary Objective
-
To study the efficacy of Priyangvaadi ganasiddha tail Pichu in the management of Parikartika.
-
To study the efficacy of Priyangvaadi ganasiddha tail Pichu in the management of Parikartika as compared to control drug yastimadu tail.
Secondary Objective
-
To study the literature of parikartika in ayurvedic classics.
-
To study the fissure in ano in modern literature.
-
To study the concept of Pichu and Tail in detail according to Sharangadhar Samhita.
-
To study the classical literature regarding Priyangvaadi gana.
Statistical analysis
Wilcoxon rank-sum test.
Time duration till following up
Follow up days is 0th, 7th, 14t, 28th days.
Time schedule of enrolment, interventions
Diagnosed patients of Fissure in Ano will be enrolled in the present study after fulfilling the inclusion criteria.
Interventions
The method of intervention is explained in Table 1
Groups |
Experimental Group |
Control Group |
---|---|---|
No. of Subject |
30 |
30 |
Drug |
Priyangvaadi gana siddhaTail Pichu |
Yastimadhu Tail Pichu |
Dose
|
External application for tail Pichu twice a day |
External application for tail Pichu twice a day |
Duration |
21 days |
21 days |
Route of administration |
Local for 15 days |
Local for 15 days |
Follow up |
On the 7th, 14th, 21st days. |
On the 7th, 14th, 21st days. |
Groups
Two groups with 30 patients in each Table 2
Group |
Sample Size |
Local Application of Ghrita |
---|---|---|
Group A |
30 |
Priyangvaadigana Siddha tail Pichu |
Group B |
30 |
Yastimadhu tail pichu |
Recruitment
Patient will be recruited by a single-arm study
Implementation
Principal invigilator will register the subject.
Data collection methods
Randomized
Assessment criteria
-
Kartanavat Vedana
-
Daha (Burning Pain)
-
Rakta Srava (Bleeding per rectum)
-
Kandu(Itching in the anus)
Assessment of pain
Kartanavat Vedana
0 Absent
1 Few hours after defecation
2 Continuous
3 As the suffer himself expresses the pain in his own terms, so this is graded, starting from mild to severe on par.
Bleeding per rectum
0 Absent
1 Bleeding with stool strip
2 Bleeding and required flush in a latrine
3 Massive bleeding
Itching in anus
0 No itching
1 Itching only when defecation
2 Itching after defecation
3 Itching occasionally during the whole day.
4 Frequent itching during the whole day
Daha (Burning Pain)
0 Absent-No Burning
1 Mild- rare Burning in the morning or at the start of defecation
2 Moderate- tolerable burning at starting & during defecation
3 Severe-burning, which is not tolerated at starting and prolonged for a long time.
Healing of fissure
Southampton wound scoring system.
Data management
Principal investigator will do the coding of data.
Ethics and dissemination
Permission for research has been taken from the Institutional Ethical Committee
Consent or assent
Written informed consent will be obtained from the patient.
Dissemination policy
For future research, results will be disseminated, and research will be published in a reputed journal
Informed consent materials
All the research related document and consent form will be given to the patients.
Discussion
According to Sushruta, Priyangvaadi gana has Vranasodaka and vranaropak properties. (Varshney & Dhyani, 2015) Most of drug in Priyangvaadi gana is kashay rasatmak and kashay rasa is Ropak and Raktastambhak in property.Regarding Parikartika management, previous work has been done, including YashtimadvadiGhruta, Pichha, Basti, VataharanTaila, Basti NirgundyadiMalhar, DashmuladiKwath. But it has been observed Priyangvaadi gana Siddha tail has not been yet used. Hence Priyangvaadi gana Siddha tail is taken for the present study.
Conclusion
Priyangvaadi taila has haemostatic activity, analgesic, wound healing activity. The predicted outcome of this analysis is that group A with intervention is a more effective intervention to group B. It is effective in subsiding the symptom of parikartika such as pain & bleeding per rectum, itching. Patients who take all follow-up after treatment will have less chance of symptom reoccurrence.
Conflict of Interest
The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest for this study.
Funding Support
The authors declare that they have no funding support for this study.