Awareness on Applications of Potodynamic Therapy in Dentistry Among Undergraduate Dental Students- a Questionnaire Survey


Saveetha Dental College and Hospitals, Saveetha Institute of Medical and Technical Sciences, Saveetha University, Chennai, Tamil Nadu, India
Department of Oral Pathology, Saveetha Dental College and Hospitals, Saveetha Institute of Medical and Technical Sciences, Saveetha University, Chennai, Tamil Nadu, India, 9884033777
Department of Biochemistry, Saveetha Dental College and Hospitals, Saveetha Institute of Medical and Technical Sciences, Saveetha University, Chennai, Tamil Nadu, India

Abstract

Photodynamic therapy is a light-based therapy that uses photosensitizers as an activating substance which has an inducing and therapeutic effect. It can be used to treat many periodontal and orthodontic problems in dentistry. It is used widely in treating many problems related to periodontics, oral lesions and to treat cariogenic bacteria. The aim of the study was to analyse the awareness on applications of photodynamic therapy in dentistry among undergraduate dental students. A questionnaire was prepared and administered to 100 participants through Google forms - an online survey platform. The study population included undergraduate dental students. Results were collected and generated in SPSS software. The results showed that the majority of participants were aware about the photodynamic therapy and its various uses in dentistry to treat patients. Photodynamic therapy is a light-based therapy which is used to treat various periodontal problems and it is used in gingival curettage and melanin pigmentation removal in dentistry. Within the limitations of the study, we conclude that the undergraduate dental students were well informed about the various uses of photodynamic therapy in dentistry.

Keywords

Photodynamic therapy, Awareness, Dentistry, Photosensitisers

Introduction

Photodynamic therapy is the treatment involving light wavelength principle to activate substances called photosensitizers. These photosensitizers produce free O2 radicals (Sibata, 2000). Oxygen radicals help in enabling the activating substances to destroy bacteria and their products. These are used to treat some skin and eye conditions, as well as certain types of cancer (Hu, Oleinick, & Hamblin, 2014). This is used to treat abnormal cells (Shree, 2019) in parts of the body that a light source can reach, such as the skin, eyes, mouth, food pipe and lungs. The scientific importance is the formation of single oxygen which produces peroxidative reactions. This causes cell death and damage. Particularly, in dentistry, it is used in treating oral cancer and many bacterial and fungal infection therapies, oral lesions (Palati et al., 2020), leukoplakia, oral lichen planus and importantly in head and neck cancer (Konopka & Goslinski, 2007).

It is very important that the applied doses of light and the activated substances are too small to achieve the therapeutic effects when given separately. The combined effects of light and the activated substances in special order may ensure therapeutic effects. Photosensitizers are chemical compounds which under the influence of light energy shift to an excited state (Hannah, 2018). On ensuing photochemical reactions, singlet oxygen and highly reactive radicals are generated in cells (Palumbo, 2007).

In dentistry, photodynamic therapy is used to treat periodontitis (Gunasekaran & Abilasha, 2016) and an alternative to antimicrobial agents to suppress subgingival (Manohar & Abilasha, 2019) species. Bacteria with dense biofilms (Dental plaque) have been found to be resistant to antimicrobial therapy (Ahad & Gheena, 2016). Photodynamic therapy is used in removing biofilm and treating antibacterial infections and antibiotics have been the traditional methods of periodontal therapy (Palati et al., 2019). Photodynamic therapy could be useful to add-on mechanic as well as antibiotics in eliminating periopathogenic bacteria (Fontana, 2009; Sheriff & Santhanam, 2018). The aim of the study was to analyse the awareness on applications of photodynamic therapy in dentistry among undergraduate dental students.

Materials and Methods

https://typeset-prod-media-server.s3.amazonaws.com/article_uploads/01325a6e-04d2-41e2-94e2-f5111c409f82/image/a9705b25-97d4-4120-a832-4aaafa2da40e-upicture1.png
Figure 1: The pie chart depicts the knowledge about photodynamic therapy among undergraduate dental students

https://typeset-prod-media-server.s3.amazonaws.com/article_uploads/01325a6e-04d2-41e2-94e2-f5111c409f82/image/98f7efa4-b740-4211-9bdd-fdfeb15e20b5-upicture2.png
Figure 2: The pie chart depicts the awareness of the photodynamic therapy used to killmicrobial cells

https://typeset-prod-media-server.s3.amazonaws.com/article_uploads/01325a6e-04d2-41e2-94e2-f5111c409f82/image/77dd3993-14dc-46d2-859e-bb075cebdb2f-upicture3.png
Figure 3: The picture depicts the awareness that photodynamic therapy is a light-based therapy used in dentistry

https://typeset-prod-media-server.s3.amazonaws.com/article_uploads/01325a6e-04d2-41e2-94e2-f5111c409f82/image/61db93bc-a793-46c3-87d6-0bd34e5cc8c2-upicture4.png
Figure 4: The picture depicts the awareness of the use of phototherapy in the treatment of cancer

https://typeset-prod-media-server.s3.amazonaws.com/article_uploads/01325a6e-04d2-41e2-94e2-f5111c409f82/image/3562c178-ba74-4103-b648-902c9d9cf287-upicture5.png
Figure 5: The picture depicts the knowledge on application of phototherapy in periodontal problems

https://typeset-prod-media-server.s3.amazonaws.com/article_uploads/01325a6e-04d2-41e2-94e2-f5111c409f82/image/80a67414-4bc9-4d23-938e-e31fe230971b-upicture6.png
Figure 6: The picture depicts the knowledge that photodynamic therapy involves thermal action

https://typeset-prod-media-server.s3.amazonaws.com/article_uploads/01325a6e-04d2-41e2-94e2-f5111c409f82/image/2c6379a0-f885-44bf-b6a3-2f0121b0de87-upicture7.png
Figure 7: The picture reveals the awareness that the therapy is used in treating inflammatory aspects of periodontal issues

https://typeset-prod-media-server.s3.amazonaws.com/article_uploads/01325a6e-04d2-41e2-94e2-f5111c409f82/image/83fc9990-044d-4b3e-a1ef-c676f8ad115c-upicture8.png
Figure 8: The picture depicts the awareness that photodynamic therapy can be used in promoting osseo-integration

https://typeset-prod-media-server.s3.amazonaws.com/article_uploads/01325a6e-04d2-41e2-94e2-f5111c409f82/image/daa8d3bc-5686-4179-bec9-0c1a5a6264d3-upicture9.png
Figure 9: The picture depicts awareness that photodynamic therapy prevents peri-implantitis

https://typeset-prod-media-server.s3.amazonaws.com/article_uploads/01325a6e-04d2-41e2-94e2-f5111c409f82/image/e483bd97-cb50-4f15-8c08-b374c6f1081c-upicture10.png
Figure 10: The picture depicts awareness that photodynamic therapy is used now in orthodontics

https://typeset-prod-media-server.s3.amazonaws.com/article_uploads/01325a6e-04d2-41e2-94e2-f5111c409f82/image/08f66c7f-9dd4-4d1c-9fc2-962742a76ce0-upicture11.png
Figure 11: The picture depicts the awareness that photodynamic therapy is used in surgical procedures

https://typeset-prod-media-server.s3.amazonaws.com/article_uploads/01325a6e-04d2-41e2-94e2-f5111c409f82/image/048339a6-7dca-4e73-b827-e1b5f0116e97-upicture12.png
Figure 12: The picture depicts the awareness of photodynamic therapy which involves photosensitisers

https://typeset-prod-media-server.s3.amazonaws.com/article_uploads/01325a6e-04d2-41e2-94e2-f5111c409f82/image/56c7d984-3c20-44c1-a699-29447174f673-upicture13.png
Figure 13: The picture depicts awareness if the photosensitisers are injected intravenously

https://typeset-prod-media-server.s3.amazonaws.com/article_uploads/01325a6e-04d2-41e2-94e2-f5111c409f82/image/6d062944-58bc-41ea-ba73-30b56a2301a2-upicture14.png
Figure 14: The picture depicts the awareness that photodynamic therapy involves electron transfer

https://typeset-prod-media-server.s3.amazonaws.com/article_uploads/01325a6e-04d2-41e2-94e2-f5111c409f82/image/4a1f7be3-85f2-4033-92ff-66ed60386215-upicture15.png
Figure 15: The picture depicts the awareness of photodynamic therapy used in gingival curettage and a melanin pigmentation removal

A self-structured questionnaire survey (Uma, 2020) based on a prospective observational study. The study comprised about 100 people (sample size) belonging to all age groups of undergraduate dental students (Prasanna & Gheena, 2016). The questionnaire was circulated on an online survey platform. The sampling method involved non - probability convenient sampling. The questionnaire was checked for validity. The results were collected and the statistics/data were analysed using SPSS software.

Results and Discussion

The results from the survey were collected and the data were analysed using SPSS software. Majority of the respondents showed a positive perception about the photodynamic therapy [Figure 1].93% of the respondents were aware of the photodynamic therapy and 7% of the respondents were not aware of the therapy.

When asked about the microbial action [Figure 2], (Sarbeen & Gheena, 2016), of photodynamic therapy, the response was positive -79% respondents answered that they were aware of the microbial action and 21% respondents were not aware. According to (Tierney, 2008), the survey concluded that patients' recovery time shortened significantly and was found to improve the cosmetic outcome in photodynamic therapy compared to surgical excision.

https://typeset-prod-media-server.s3.amazonaws.com/article_uploads/01325a6e-04d2-41e2-94e2-f5111c409f82/image/f9b086b4-4fdd-41a5-bc2a-5a13c70038d2-upicture16.png
Figure 16: Association between gender and awareness of photodynamic therapy in dentistry

https://typeset-prod-media-server.s3.amazonaws.com/article_uploads/01325a6e-04d2-41e2-94e2-f5111c409f82/image/e7efce4b-dfc7-4093-9b55-2bd40f516db2-upicture17.png
Figure 17: Association between gender and knowledge on the role of photodynamic therapy in the treatment of periodontal problems

https://typeset-prod-media-server.s3.amazonaws.com/article_uploads/01325a6e-04d2-41e2-94e2-f5111c409f82/image/d833f79d-d154-48f0-8a6e-c9fa93184086-upicture18.png
Figure 18: Association between gender and knowledge on the role of photodynamic therapy in treating inflammatory aspects of periodontal issues

https://typeset-prod-media-server.s3.amazonaws.com/article_uploads/01325a6e-04d2-41e2-94e2-f5111c409f82/image/d730f4e0-e0ab-41e4-9b29-3f4ce1f2910b-upicture19.png
Figure 19: Association between gender and knowledge on the role of photodynamic therapy in promoting osseointegration

https://typeset-prod-media-server.s3.amazonaws.com/article_uploads/01325a6e-04d2-41e2-94e2-f5111c409f82/image/16aef6ea-13d9-4bab-afe7-32e1b567a709-upicture20.png
Figure 20: Association between gender and knowledge on the role of photodynamic therapy inorthodontics

When asked if it was light-based therapy [Figure 3], 81% of respondents answered positively, 19% of respondents were not aware. According to (Osiecka, Jurczyszyn, & Ziółkowski, 2012), Osiecka BJ et al., this light-based therapy cured 6 patients totally, 4 lesions decreased in size and 18 lesions disappeared. Also, when asked if this therapy helps in treating cancer (tumour) [Figure 4], 91% believed that it helps in treating cancer and 9% answered negatively.

When asked the study population about treating periodontal problems [Figure 5], 59% of respondents answered that the therapy could treat the problem and 41% of respondents didn't think so. Also, when asked if photodynamic therapy involves thermal action, 63% of respondents were aware and 37% we're unaware [Figure 6].

Also, when asked about the inflammatory aspects of periodontal issues to be treated [Figure 7], 54% of respondents answered positively and 46% of respondents didn't think so. According to (Fontana, 2009), photodynamic therapy killed bacteria present in suspension, which was helpful in treating inflammatory aspects.

When asked, if the therapy is used in promoting osseointegration [Figure 8], (Sukumaran & Padavala, 2018), 69% of respondents were aware and 31% of respondents were unaware. According to (Faria, 2015), they concluded that the use of photosensitisers by the therapy demonstrated a tendency to stimulate bone formation, similar to bone grafting.

According to (Javed, 2017), the participants of this study who smoked daily when the treatment was given patients showed a noticeable reduction in peri-implantitis [Figure 9].

When asked, if the therapy was used in orthodontics [Figure 10], (Harrita & Santhanam, 2019), 54% of respondents were aware and 46% of respondents were unaware. According to (Panhóca et al., 2016), this survey concluded that Photodynamic therapy could be used as an adjutant and a convenient agent to promote oral decontamination in clinical practice.

When asked if this photodynamic therapy specially helps in surgical procedures - 72% of respondents answered 'yes' and 28% answered 'no'[Figure 11], (Krishnan, 2018). The awareness of photodynamic therapy which involves photosensitisers. Photodynamic therapy involves photosensitisers, 74% of students knew about it and 26% of students did not know about it [Figure 12].

When asked if the photodynamic therapy involved photosensitisers which are injected intravenously [Figure 13], 64% of respondents answered that they were aware and 36% of respondents were not aware. According to (Kramer, 1996), this photodynamic therapy was tested using lipoprotein - derived benzoporphyrin derived mono-acid effectively, which closed experimental choroidal neovascularization with light doses.

Also, when asked if the photodynamic therapy involves electron transfer which occurs in the presence of oxygen [Figure 14], 75% of respondents were aware of it and 25% respondents were unaware. According to (Sperandio, 2013), this photodynamic therapy works by radical - enhanced photoinduced electron transfer mechanisms.

When asked if the treatment is used in gingival curettage and melanin pigmentation removal [Figure 15] - 72% respondents answered that they were aware that it could be used in the treatment and 28% were not aware.

Association between gender and awareness of photodynamic therapy in dentistry; knowledge on the role of photodynamic therapy in the treatment of periodontal problems; in treating inflammatory aspects of periodontal issues; in promoting osseointegration and the role in orthodontics; X-axis represents 'Gender of the respondents' and Y-axis represents 'Total students who were aware (Blue) or not aware (Red)'. (Chi-square analysis, P-value = 0.101;0.213; 0.190; 0.780 and 0.265 respectively) Statistically, not significant. Both the male and female population were equally aware.

Figure 20; Figure 19; Figure 18; Figure 17; Figure 16. The study assessed the views of a small population and hence is not representative of the whole population.

Figure 16 shows that, The X-axis represents 'Gender of the respondents' and Y-axis represents 'Total students who were aware (Blue) or not aware (Red)' (Chi-square analysis, P value=0.101) Statistically not significant. Both the male and female population were equally aware.

Figure 17shows that, The X-axis represents 'Gender of the respondents' and Y-axis represents 'The students who were aware (Blue) or not aware (Red)' (Chi-square analysis, P value=0.213, P >0.05, Statistically not significant. Level of awareness among the male and female population was found to be similar.

Figure 18shows that, The X-axis represents 'Gender of the respondents' and Y-axis represents 'The students who were aware (Blue) or not aware (Red)'(Chi-square analysis, P value=0.190, P > 0.05, Statistically not significant)Level of awareness among the male and female population was found to be similar.

Figure 19 shows that, The X-axis represents 'Gender of the respondents' and Y-axis represents 'The students who were aware (Blue) or not aware (Red)' (Chi-square analysis, P value=0.780, P > 0.05, Statistically not significant). Level of awareness among the male and female population was found to be similar.

Figure 20 shows that, The X-axis represents 'Gender of the respondents' and Y-axis represents 'The students who were aware (Blue) or not aware (Red)' (Chi-square analysis, P value=0.265, P > 0.05, Statistically not significant). Level of awareness among the male and female population was found to be similar.

Conclusion

Photodynamic therapy is a light-based therapy which is used to treat various periodontal problems and it is used in gingival curettage and melanin pigmentation removal in dentistry. The survey led us to know that the majority of the students who were assessed had good knowledge about the various applications of photodynamic therapy in dentistry.

Funding Support

The authors declare that they have no funding support for this study.

Conflict of Interest

The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest for this study.